On the big day, after four days of island fun with just 35 family members and friends, all their planning paid off.

Vanessa was stunning in a two-piece Monique Lhuillier ensemble, and she and her new husband danced the night away barefoot, before a grand farewell of fireworks.

"It was really just a small group of people, people that they really love and trust and people that when they look back on it in 20 years they're still going to be friends with those people," Garcia said.